Toluna: People, polls and opinions
Register   Sign In: Sign in (Forgot your password?)
Site: United Kingdom
Welcome to Toluna! The place to voice your opinion and know what other people think!
Answer Ask Earn
Already 18 665 opinions
added today.
Add yours now
Let 1 000 000 members
answer your questions!
Earn rewards and
test products

Wind that Shakes the Barley, The

 
 
Opinion by You! 
OpinionMasterCreated By
OpinionMast...
Films & CinemaSee More of
Films &...
3Opinions:
3
Submit
About the topic
 
Author
OpinionMaster
OpinionMaster
Member Since: 10/03/2008
Country: United Kingdom
Age: 36
Created 2 polls and 3977 topics
Novice Member
Novice Member
Like OpinionMaster?
Facts
Category: Films & Cinema
Subcategory: Drama
Opened: 16/11/2006
Close: 07/10/2008
Total Opinions: 3
Status: ClosedText
created by OpinionMaster
Language: English
View on the web: N/A
Picture: show
Opinions   Related   Tools  
   All Opinions
Sort by recentuseful   
 
Fudgibo_UNSUBSCRIBED
I too got seriously interested in Irish History after England v Ireland at Croke Park, 2007, scene of the original Bloody Sunday in 1920. My Great Grandfather was there and was also Michael Collins intelligence officer. There are few left in my family who have any history to pass down, so I loved this because it was the life my Great Grandfather lived and provides clever comment on a time when pride, courage and political beliefs led many down a very dark path.
 
Opinion by Fudgibo_UNS...

bigmamma3
i haven't watyched this film so cannot really sat anything but will try to and then start another opinion
 
Opinion by bigmamma3

kipperling
I started being interested in the story of Ireland when I saw the rugby game between Ireland and England a couple years ago. They sang a rousing 'anthem' (Ireland's Calling) about the freedom beauty and history of this amazing land. Rugy is a team sport so far without the hooliganism that has plagued football. In that game in Landsdown England was disappointingly playing rough and captain Martin Johnson was not cordial towards their host. Whether this is machoism or British self-importance, it was very unsportsmanlike.

Ken Loach in the great British realist film-making tradition, is one who prefers to use the local people for his films so we have Irish actors. This film is not patriotic rubbish, it offers behind-the-scenes sequence of events that happened in history. Anyone watching this film would feel powerless and angry at the level of betrayal, and devious British politics of the day. Two brothers fighting for what they believe in, with terrible consequences ... echoing what's happened in the split. I still have no plans to visit Northern Ireland.
 
Opinion by kipperling

If this opinion offends you, click here to report it
Copyright © 2008 Toluna Inc. All rights reserved.